By SECRETARY HAIG'S REACH EXCEEDS HIS GRASP
About 11 P.M. Tuesday, after a long, bruising day of trench warfare with Secretary of State Alexander M. Haig Jr., the White House was uncertain whether he would resign. Dave Gergen, a top White House official, telephoned William Dyess, an aide to Mr. Haig, to ask: ''Is he or isn't he?'' It was a pivotal moment in a bureaucratic battle that almost turned the first-ranking member of the Reagan Cabinet into its first political fatality, the victim partly of his own urge to take full command in an Administration where the President reserves that power to himself and expects from his Cabinet the collegial give-and-take of team play. The showdown was over power and prerogatives rather than over policies. Mr. Haig shares Mr. Reagan's broad foreign policy objectives. But his confrontational assertiveness rubbed against the more relaxed style of the President, who apparently had promised his Secretary of State more authority than he really wanted to surrender to any one man, and then shied away from curbing Mr. Haig until he himself felt challenged.