COULD HOLMES HAVE LOST DECISION?
By Michael Katz, Special To the New York Times
Larry Holmes, in a self-controlled and intelligent performance, had thoroughly beaten a courageous but outclassed Gerry Cooney for 12 rounds. In the 13th, Holmes turned on the power and, with Cooney about to slump to the canvas for the second time in the World Boxing Council heavyweight title fight, his trainer, Victor Valle, entered the ring at the Caesars Palace parking lot and the referee ended the fight. There were eight seconds left in the round. Holmes had defended his title successfully for the 12th time, the 11th with a knockout, and the undefeated champion was never more convincing than he was Friday night. Except to the judges. ''It was going to be a robbery,'' Don King, the co-promoter and Holmes's adviser, said today. Had not the referee Mills Lane taken 3 points from Cooney for low blows, two of the judges, Duane Ford and Dave Moretti, would have had the challenger ahead after 12 rounds. As it was, they had Holmes ahead, 113-111, on the 10-point scoring system. The other judge, Jerry Roth, had Holmes ahead by 115-109. Ford and Moretti gave Cooney seven rounds and Holmes only five. Roth had those figures reversed.