ST. BART'S: NEW PLAN THAT FACES OLD ISSUES
AnAppraisal When officials of St. Bartholomew's Episcopal Church in 1981 unveiled the first design for the skyscraper they hope to build beside their landmark church on Park Avenue, the tower of reflective glass by Edward Durell Stone Associates was so inappropriate that the question seemed not whether the city's Landmarks Preservation Commission would reject it, but when. Though both the church and the Landmarks Commission took their time in presenting the design and deliberating over it, the answer, when it finally came last June, was just what had been expected. The commission said no, and its members denounced the building so vehemently that another question soon arose - could any office tower at this site win the commission's approval? A Revised Design The coming year seems fairly certain to provide an answer, for St. Bartholomew's went before the Landmarks Commission last week to try again with a new, and substantially revised, design. The architect is the same - Peter Capone, president of the Edward Durell Stone firm - but the buildings could not be more different. Indeed, like a politician who runs against his own record, Mr. Capone's new design renounces every principle of his first one.