COLLINS HIS SUCCESSOR; His Eligibility to the Office Since Jan. 1 Is Questioned, However. DISPUTE OVER THE LAW Governor May Have Power to Appoint Hulbert to His Old Position. COMMA FIGURES IN CASE Justice Proskauer Holds That the Office Became Vacant April 9 -- Craig's Fight Upheld.
Supreme Court sustains contention of Controller Craig that he forfeited office as Pres of Bd of Aldermen when he accepted appt on Finger Lakes Comm; declines to discuss decision; Mayor Hylan hopes Gov Smith win reappoint him; Hulbert managed campaign in 1917 that resulted in Craig's first election