ISRAELI GENERAL ASSAILS SUPERIORS
By Charles Mohr Special to The New York Times
Maj Gen A Sharon who led Israeli forces across Suez Canal charges on Nov 8 that his superiors may have been too slow to reinforce and exploit his breakthrough, thereby losing chance to achieve a decisive victory over Egypt; Sharon, presently reservist and head of hawkish, right-wing slate in forthcoming parliamentary elections, contends in interview that Israeli high command moved too slowly and cautiously from outset of war on Oct 6 and 'failed to understand the element of time, which was critical'; says Israel was strong enough in 1st hours of conflict to avoid 'the disaster that befell us,' adding that 'what happened to us should not have happened'; asserts that mil command delayed for 36 to 40 hours pushing of reinforcements across canal bridgehead, delay which meant that Egyptain 3d Corps on eastern bank of canal south of Israeli bridgehead had not been encircled or reduced as a mil force by time 1st UN cease-fire was imposed on Oct 22; other Israeli officers contend that Egyptians 'failed to read the battle correctly' and to grasp what was happening after canal crossing; Sharon contends, however, that Israelis were equally remiss and were unaware of exact nature of battle; bolsters argument by noting that only high-ranking official to visit bridgehead during 1st critical days was Defense Min M Dayan 'the only one' who 'understood what was happening'; explains that other comdrs believed that he had failed to secure bridgeheads and its approaches and were reluctant to risk funneling 2d division into battle; says his tanks penetrated 15 mi across canal and into Egypt before being reinforced, but that he was ordered to recall them; asserts that after bridgehead west of canal had been reinforced by 2d armored division his own force was prevented from racing north to attempt to encircle Egyptian 2d Corps, which occupies eastern end of canal; says he had capability to encircle 2d Corps, which would have resulted in neutralization of most of Egyptian forces; says his divison met little initial resistance on west bank of canal, but that major force he used to push back elements of 2d Egyptian Corps that could have threatened corridor leading to bridgehead met with bitter opposition and failed to push Egyptians back very far; crux of controversy surrounding Snaron's accusations is that other gens, who did not agree with mil assessments, hesitated to send reinforcements across canal during critical early stage of conflict, when large and easy gains could have been made; Sharon's criticism reptdly is aimed at Maj Gen S Gonen, Lt Gen C Bar-Lev, and Israeli C/S Lt Gen D Elazar; has fought in all of Israel's wars; retired from army in July to form Likud--coalition of opposition parties critical of govt of Premier Meir; illus with Dayan near Suez Canal on Oct 16