WHY SHERLOCK HOLMES FASCINATES AMERICANS
How can one explain the American fascination, to the point of exuberant idolatry, with Sherlock Holmes? The fascination finds its latest expression in ''Young Sherlock Holmes,'' the sumptuous period film produced by Steven Spielberg, an engaging trifle in which the great detective makes his imagined first bow as a schoolboy. The idolatry touches its seasonal peak on Friday, when the Baker Street Irregulars converge for their annual dinner at the Regency Hotel. That night, a hundred-odd more or less grown men will assemble to commemorate Holmes's 132d birthday. The evening always commences with what are known as canonical toasts - elaborate and sometimes labored tributes to Holmes, Dr. Watson and assorted bit players in the canon of Holmes's adventures, such as Irene Adler, the siren born in New Jersey who upstaged and outwitted the sleuth in ''A Scandal in Bohemia.'' This particular game has been afoot since the 1930's, when the Irregulars first began gathering to ponder the Sacred Writings at the call of Christopher Morley, Elmer Davis, Rex Stout, Edgar Smith, Vincent Starrett and a survivor among the founders, Julian Wolff, M.D., who still presides. American devotees have gone to remarkable lengths to establish that the detective and the good Dr. Watson were real people, and that the putative author, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, was merely Watson's literary agent.